Subject: Why So Gloomy: "It's The Worst Outlook I Have Ever Seen" Says Governor ...

View this email online if it doesn't display correctly
                                                                                 Saturday 2nd December 2023
Hi Friend,

Andrew Bailey, the governor of the Bank of England, has hit back at critics who have claimed he has taken an "ultra pessimistic" view of the UK economy.

This week, Bailey painted an extremely dim picture of the UK economy, claiming that its present potential growth trajectory is the "worst" he has ever seen in his career.

"I have been written up this week as being an ultra-pessimist, but I don't see it that way. I see it as a realist view,' Bailey told Staffordshire's Daily Focus newspaper.

The Bank's latest forecasts indicate the economy will barely grow at all next year, or in 2025. The Governor has said the outlook for the economy is the worst he has ever seen. Britain struggles to boost low levels of growth, as taxes and interest rates rise.

The Bank of England Governor raised concerns over the UK's future prospects just days after the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) issued forecasts for the UK economy slightly more optimistic than the Bank of England.

In an interview with The Chronicle in Newcastle, Mr Bailey said: "If you look at what I call the potential growth rates of the economy, there's no doubt it's lower than it has been in much of my working life.
"It does concern me the supply side of the economy has slowed. It does concern me a lot."

Is The Governor Genetically Pessimistic?
When asked at the OBR press conference "Why Are Your Forecasts for GDP Growth So much Stronger Than The Bank of England's November Forecasts?" Professor David Miles said (with a smile) "Because we are genetically more optimistic than the Central Bank". It's a fair point..

He then went one to say "Actually, that's not really true. The variance is best explained by the differences over the underlying trend rate of growth and assessments of total factor productivity. Adding the possibility of a possible varying stance on the future path of interest rates may also come into play. But in general the Bank has a more cautious, more conservative, more pessimistic view."

Predictions of weak supply growth are one reason Mr Bailey and his colleagues on the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) are keeping interest rates high. The governor added to warnings from Huw Pill, the Bank's chief economist, the supply side of the economy, which includes the availability of labour, could keep inflation stubbornly high over the coming years as a result of the ensuing pressure on wages.

So What About Rates?
The Bank of England will not cut interest rates for the "foreseeable future", Andrew Bailey has said, warning it was "too soon" to discuss the prospect of large-scale monetary easing. He warned the next stage of cutting inflation would be "hard work".

So far, inflation has fallen from a peak of 11.1pc in October 2022 to 4.6pc last month, when a drop in the energy price cap pulled the headline rate down from September's 6.7pc. The Governor said the job is not done yet, and warned families not to expect any steep falls in interest rates as the Bank battles to get prices back to its 2pc target.

"By the end of the first quarter next year, when a lot of that unwind will have happened, we may be a bit under 4pc (CPI)  but we'll still have 2pc to go, maybe. And the rest of it has to be done by policy and monetary policy. And policy is operating in what I call a restrictive way at the moment."

He stressed that this requires rates to stay at their current level of 5.25pc for some time, despite the pain it inflicts on borrowers. He said: "I am very conscious of the position of the less well-off but we do have to get it down to 2pc and that's why I have pushed back of late against assumptions that we're talking about cutting interest rates or we will be cutting interest in anything like the foreseeable future because it's too soon to have that discussion."

Financial markets are currently betting that the first rate cut, from 5.25pc to 5pc, will come in the summer of 2024. Bailey and other Bank rate-setters have recently pushed back against financial market speculation that indicates at least two rates cuts before November next year, taking the base rate to around 4.75 per cent. That ain't go to happen says the governor!

Why So Gloomy? The "Sexy Turtle" will have his sway ... but the OBR will have it's day ...
Last week we warned of the problems with Jeremy Hunt's Autumn statement. This week, Richard Hughes Chairman of the OBR told MP's it was "difficult to assess the credibility of the government's spending plans because of the lack of detail from March 2025 onwards.

This is the article from Mehreen Khan in the Times on the 28th November.

The chancellor’s goal to have debt falling within the next five years is at high risk from spending demands to help motorists and government departments, the fiscal watchdog has warned.

Richard Hughes, chairman of the Office for Budget Responsibility, told MPs there was a “very big fiscal risk” baked into Jeremy Hunt’s autumn statement last week, which implied big spending cuts to public spending that are unlikely to be maintained.

The chancellor’s tax and spending plans give him £13 billion in headroom to meet a self-imposed target to have debt falling by 2028-2029. But the OBR has warned that this fiscal space has been earned at the expense of departmental spending, which is due to fall by £19 billion in the same year.

“There are very big fiscal risks partly because the spending plans are so uncertain and partly because they haven’t been set beyond 2025,” Hughes told the Treasury select committee. “If you are planning real-term reductions in spending in particular areas, the later you leave it the harder it is to deliver. The risks in this section of public spending has gone up … we don’t know whether the plans are plausible or not.”

Hughes also noted that the chancellor was likely to follow his predecessors and extend the freeze in fuel duty from April next year, costing the Treasury around £6.5 billion.

High inflation has resulted in massive windfall taxes for the government as businesses and households are paying higher income tax levels due to frozen thresholds since 2021. But high inflation also erodes spending on unprotected governmental departments, which is not rising in line with prices over the next two years, according to the chancellor’s plans.

Hughes said it was “difficult to assess the credibility of the government’s spending plans after March 2025 as the government doesn’t have spending plans”. The Treasury’s next spending review is penciled in for 2024-2025.

“We know that more recently governments have tended to have vague spending plans in the run up to the spending review and when the review arrives they chuck an extra £20 billion to £30 billion into the pot,” he said.


Mehreen Khan Economics Editor The Times 28th November 2023
That's all for this week! Have a great week ahead ...

John
To understand the markets, you have to understand the economics ...
© 2023 John Ashcroft, Economics, Strategy and Financial Markets, experience worth sharing.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________
The material is based upon information which we consider to be reliable but we do not represent that it is accurate or complete and it should not be relied upon as such. We accept no liability for errors, or omissions of opinion or fact. In particular, no reliance should be placed on the comments on trends in financial markets. The receipt of this email should not be construed as the giving of advice relating to finance or investment.

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________
If you do not wish to receive any further Saturday Economist updates, you can unsubscribe or update your details, using the buttons below or drop me an email at jkaonline@me.com. If you enjoy the content, why not forward to a friend, they can sign up here ...
_______________________________________________________________________________________
We have updated our privacy policy to address Europe's General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). The policy changes include explaining in more detail how we use your information, including your choices, rights, and controls. We have published a GDPR compliance page about the regulation and the steps we have taken as part of our compliance process. Your privacy is important to us.
For details of our Privacy Policy   and our Terms and Conditions check out our main web site. John Ashcroft and Company.com
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Copyright © 2023 The Saturday Economist, All rights reserved. You are receiving this email as a member of the Saturday Economist Mailing List or the Dimensions of Strategy List. You may have joined the list from Linkedin, Facebook, Google+ or one of the related web sites. You may have attended one of our economics presentations. Our mailing address is: The Saturday Economist, Centurion House, 129 Deansgate, Manchester, M3 3WR.
LikeTwitterPinterestGooglePlusLinkedInForward
Tower 12, Bridge Street, M3 3BZ, Manchester, United Kingdom
You may unsubscribe or change your contact details at any time.