Subject: "Appreciating The Evolutionary Edge" November 29th

The Co-Intelligence Institute

November 2023 Newsletter


Last Chance to Join Our Celebratory Gathering, The Tao of Democracy and Beyond!


The Tao of Democracy and Beyond: A Gathering of Hearts and Minds sessions are now well and truly underway and 2 of the 3 sessions have already taken place. In these sessions we’re celebrating the 20th anniversary of the publication of the Tao of Democracy. Our first call explored the Metacrisis whilst the second call, a more intimate gathering, discussed  “The power of the stories we tell ourselves about our shared future.” You can watch the video recording of that call here.

The final session of this celebratory gathering will take place on Wednesday November 29th (1-3pm Eastern time).  So, whether you haven’t yet managed to join us or have already participated in the previous calls, do come along for our final call. This is a celebration of you as part of our extended CII community!

We’ll be exploring the following: Appreciating the Evolutionary Edge - What social innovations have been calling to you these days? What evolutionary experiments in healing and transformation have been inspiring you?


Please Help: Tell us what you value in CII's work...


We’re preparing to launch CII’s end of year fundraiser to sustain a number of projects aimed to grow co-intelligence and wise democracy at a time when the world sorely needs them. As part of that we’re reaching out and having conversations with the institute’s friends and supporters. We’d like to know what you feel is important in CII’s work - e.g the work of both the institute and Tom Atlee. Considering our gatherings, this newsletter, the resources we offer, Tom’s blog and mailings, and so on, what do you particularly value?



Some participants from our recent gatherings have started to share ideas which we’ve entered into a Slido poll. Help CII get its fundraiser going by

sharing your own thoughts and thumbs-upvoting other peoples’ comments that resonate with you here on this Slido poll link. Two or three minutes should be all it takes. Thank you!


The First International Dynamic Facilitation Gathering

Dynamic Facilitation (DF) is a potent group facilitation methodology that CII has been inspired by and promoted for many years. It demonstrates many patterns of wise democracy such as Using diversity and disturbance creatively, Feeling heard, All concerns addressed, and Generating shared orientation to name a few.


You can read more about how it works and its history here on a dedicated page on the CII website.


The method has taken root most prominently in German speaking nations. So this year the largest ever gathering of DFers (Dynamic Facilitation practitioners) took place in Munich, Germany on October 6-8th to celebrate the fifth anniversary of the Dynamic Facilitation Association. The focus of the gathering was to explore how DF could make a larger impact in the world. It included a whole host of Open Space style sessions, which took place using Dynamic Facilitation in the beautiful venue of a church in the outskirts of Munich.


Rosa Zubizarreta and Andy Paice of CII attended the event where connections and insights were woven together as practitioners exchanged their facilitation experience and worked on how DF might be applied to challenges at different levels.


The Story of Taiwan's Remarkable Digital Democracy

Yen Lin Huang - also known as ‘mashbean’ - from Taiwan’s Ministry of Digital Affairs joined us for a fascinating Real World Co-Intelligence community learning call on Friday October 27th.

Mashbean told us the story of Taiwan’s digital democracy, an incredible example of the emergence of a partnership culture between government and citizens within the context of the country’s perilous relationship with the People’s Republic of China.
 
The evolution of Taiwan’s democracy was intertwined with the birth of its internet culture from the 1990s onwards. Online activists and developers involved in social movements - including CII’s good friend Audrey Tang - became involved in civic tech initiatives such as g0v (pronounced “gov zero”). Following the Sunflower Movement occupation of parliament in 2014 and numerous other student-led protests, many of these civic hackers found themselves integrated into the workings of national government through citizen deliberation processes such as vTaiwan and more recently the founding of the Ministry of Digital Affairs.

These days the Ministry is exploring how AI can best be used for the public good and is seeking to disseminate its vision of society based on Plurality - cooperation across diversity.

Watch the video recording of the call here.



Join November's Community Call Exploring Appreciative Capacitance


Our next monthly community call will be on Friday November 24th. We anticipate many attendees from the US may be with family or busy the day after Thanksgiving. So rather than host a featured guest for our usual Real World Co-Intelligence (RWCI) learning call, we’re holding a session to explore the challenging, juicy intersection between two Wise Democracy Patterns: Capacitance and Appreciative Thinking.


Capacitance is the ability to tolerate disturbance, complexity, uncertainty, mystery, paradox, conflict, crisis, diversity and so on - to abide with them in an unsettled but attentive state.  Appreciative Thinking seeks to understand and value people and things as they are - in ways that enhance the value and aliveness in and around them.

 
Together they generate what we like to call appreciative capacitance. 


Appreciative capacitance is relevant at a personal level as we witness crises around the world in real time… in relationships and groups where we seek to creatively address disturbance and conflict … and at systemic and cultural levels where our collective stories and how our societies are organized enhance or undermine our ability to engage together with disturbance and crisis to make life better for all concerned.

In our next community session, we’ll revisit these two patterns, explore what appreciative capacitance might be, share insights and stories related to them all, and go through some facilitated exercises to support appreciative capacitance in our lives. 

Nov 24 - 1pm-2.30pm EST, 6-7.30pm GMT Register here.


November's Wise Democracy Pattern

November’s  pattern - Realizing Essential Aspirations - explores one of the ways to make collective decisions without majoritarian battles, seeking instead “the sense of the whole” that arises from greater understanding of the perspectives and needs of all involved.  For many practical approaches, see “Finding our way together - through innovations in shared understanding.” 


Realizing Essential Aspirations

When adversaries or communities identify underlying motivators that make sense to everyone involved, they become able to transcend surface differences to co-create shared paths forward. So help people realize essential, deeply felt principles, interests, needs, values, goals, or narratives that generate trust and joint action for mutually satisfying, broadly beneficial outcomes.

Featured Question

What do we actually need and want that nearly everyone probably needs and wants?


Featured Resource

Convergent Facilitation

Nonviolent Communication - Feelings and Needs



November's Co-Intelligence Poem
(The first part of this poem by Tom Atlee was presented in October. Below is the rest of it. For continuity, the middle three stanzas appear in both presentations. The full poem can be read here)


The Unholy Majority (Part 2)


…. The system demands
  that the whole become parts,
  and that the parts masquerade as the whole —
  that each special interest act like it is The General Interest.


And the system demands, as well,
  that when a part wins, when it is a majority,
  we acknowledge it as the Whole, as US.


It is all fantasm,
  all a lie, I tell you —
  The Emperor’s New Clothes —
  a loudly proclaimed virtual nothing
  that drains into part-isanship
  all the energies and gifts we could use
  to co-discover our wisdom together
  as whole communities,
  as a healed and healthy world.


So the majoritarian system consumes and digests
  the righteous passions of our well-divided interests,
  motivating and shape-shifting and battling
  in its search for majority support
  and thus victory
  and thus the dominance and resources
  of concentrated power controlled by the victor,
  forcing other interests into loser status
  of “minority”
  so they will fight to win back the reins.


And thus the battle rages back and forth.

Or at least seems to.


Meanwhile those who own and benefit from the game itself
  (who support both sides to maintain access to
  the public treasury,
  the natural wealth of The Commons,
  and the game-shaping activity
  of deciding public policy)
  continue to design the game to be losable
  only by the players,
  not the owners,
  and in the process lose their own access to heaven
  for the eye of the needle is far too small
  to admit their heavily laden camels.


Meanwhile the general interest, the common good,
  not only loses
  but is not even part of the game, part of the conversation,
  except insofar as all sides claim it as theirs.


With “God on our side”
  the partisan parts abscond with the holy whole.


God only knows,
  this won’t change
  until the players stop playing the game
  and change it.


And if the Whole could speak, it might well say
  that changing the game is not confined to
  changing the rules of majoritarianism
  so that
  the Rule of the Biggest Part
  is more legitimately seen as
  the Rule of The Whole.
  No.


Changing the game is about enabling the Rule of the Whole.


Changing the game may require helping majoritarianism
  work fairly for real majorities, yes,
  but only as a stepping stone —
  because it IS only a stepping stone.


Ultimately, changing the game is not about the majority.
  It is about the real Whole,
  about the wisdom that arises from turning
  towards each other
  instead of against each other
  or away.


  It is about striving
  towards the rule of, by and for The Whole,
  a whole which includes Them
  and Us
  Together.


The Rule of the Whole
  is a horizon, an invitation, an adventure.
  We will never reach it, it is not a place to stop.
  It is so deep, so wide,
  so ever-changing into newness
  that we can only live it as a journey
  or a conversation.
  When we seek it, when we travel it,
  when we accept that we are pioneers of life’s emergent wisdom,
  we meet each Other
  and we hear
  and are heard
  and new things become possible
  that were never possible before.
  Because when our differences are heard
  our diverse parts discover their kinship
  and their power to dance creatively together.


Then the Whole can find its voice
  and its will.


And it will —
  if it is given a form to manifest in,
  if it is given a wiser democratic system,
  one that brings us together
  and taps the font of our buried co-creativity.


The system that holds us in thrall
  is built on not hearing each other
  so that we will remain a
  part.


  The system that frees us
  will be built on hearing each other
  so that we can expand
  through each other’s eyes and lives
  to see more and become
  ever more truly whole
  together.


So the sacred secret strategy is this:
  The game of the whole
  cannot be won by any part
  but only by the Whole.
  That is the only game
  that We the People
  can win.


Truly, as sure as the sun is setting:
  That is the only game
  that We the People
  can win.


On that path,
  control and rightness
  cease to claim our passion.
  Instead,
  our hearts, minds and spirits
  dedicate themselves together to create
  not just a world that works for all,
  but the means by which the world can create
  a world that works for all,
  over and over again,
  born from the gifts of all,
  evolving forever from the lives of all
  toward the dreams of all,
  knowing that
  It is All that Matters. 


For the sake of the sunrise
  we are called:


We are All.
  In This.
      Together.


Tom Atlee
 Nov 6, 2002



Out beyond ideas
 of wrongdoing and rightdoing,
 there is a field.
 I’ll meet you there.


— Rumi



Powered by:
GetResponse